Judge Explains Compassionate Release of Murderer Gary Anderson From Northern Ireland Jail

Mr Justice Coghlin has publicly explained his decision to grant temporary compassionate release to convicted murderer Gary Anderson, who failed to return to Maghaberry Prison. Anderson, 55, was sentenced to 15 years for the murder of Karol Kelly in Londonderry in 2018 and has been at large since his release in March.

The judge stated that such temporary releases are standard procedure, often approved by the prison governor or the Department of Justice. However, in cases involving high-risk prisoners, the application is referred to a High Court judge for a judicial review.

Mr Justice Coghlin reviewed Anderson's case on 19 March, specifically addressing an application for a three-day compassionate release to attend a family funeral. The judge acknowledged that Anderson was considered a low risk for reoffending or absconding at the time. A previous application for compassionate release in February, also approved by the judge, saw Anderson return to prison without incident. The PSNI was notified of both releases.

The current policy framework, established following a 2008 review by Sir John Steele, permits such releases under stringent conditions. Anderson signed a release form stipulating his return to custody by 17:00 BST on 26 March. He was also subject to an electronic tag and a curfew during his temporary liberty.